I've made the thread. Since we've decided on what the first story is going to be, we should set the stage on what'll happen. I'm thinking it's basically a situation where Luffy and Chopper have gotten lost and end up in the Fairy Tail guild where they start hitting it off with Natsu and Chopper at first but an accident where one of them hits the other escalates into a fight between them until one side loses. Whichever side loses will be the eternal losers for each revisit to this story. They'll be like Tom and Jerry, trying to think of different ways to get back at the other side but end up failing each time.
I was also thinking that maybe, if we didn't have a preference, we could maybe use luck to determine this. Like when they start fighting, we'd each roll a number using a random number generator online or something and whoever has the highest number lands a hit. And the one who manages to hit the opponent 10 times wins.
https://diaperedanime.com/forum/show...120/index.html