I don't mind. We can go with the first one if that's the one you prefer?
I would suspect with the new Pyramid Head - he wouldn't let Heather out of his sight at all and would probably follow her most of the time? I don't think he would attack anyone or do anything unless he knew Heather was in danger. This would also allow Heather to go about Silent Hill a little more freely. There can still be other monsters trying to hurt her and townsfolk trying to hurt her as well but I would suspect Vincent would be curious about this new Pyramid Head and would try to help Heather discover why the new PH is doing this to her even though he does have motives against her and same with Claudia. I don't know Vincent or Claudia's characters that well but I can do some of the townspeople/monsters.